How to Tell if Your Ankle is Broken, Sprained, or a High Ankle Sprain
How to Tell if Your Ankle is Broken, Sprained, or a High Ankle Sprain
If you live in Colorado Springs, chances are you lead an active lifestyle. Whether you are hiking the trails at Garden of the Gods, running around your neighborhood, or simply missing a step while navigating downtown, ankle injuries are incredibly common. But when you hear that dreaded “pop” and your ankle instantly starts to swell, the immediate question is always: Is my ankle broken, or is it just a sprain? Or even more frustratingly, could it be the notoriously stubborn high ankle sprain?
At Easy Orthopedics, a non-insurance-based, non-operative orthopedic practice right here in Colorado Springs, we evaluate and treat these injuries constantly. Our focus is on getting you an accurate diagnosis fast—often with same-day or next-day appointments—so you can start the right recovery plan immediately.
To help you decipher your injury and figure out your next steps, we’ve taken the most frequently asked questions on Google about ankle injuries and answered them below.
How can you tell if your ankle is broken or just sprained?
A standard ankle sprain happens when the ligaments (the tough, elastic bands of tissue holding your bones together) are overstretched or torn. A broken ankle, or ankle fracture, means one or more of the actual bones in the joint have cracked, chipped, or snapped.
Because both injuries cause localized pain, swelling, and bruising, it can be tough to tell them apart without an X-ray. However, there are a few key clues you can look for:
- Location of Pain: If the pain is exclusively in the soft tissue just below and in front of the bony bump on the outside of your ankle, it’s highly likely to be a sprain. If the bony bumps themselves (the medial or lateral malleolus) are extremely tender to the touch, you might have a break.
- Visible Deformity: If your ankle looks crooked, misshapen, or is pointing in a completely unnatural direction, it is almost certainly a fracture or a severe dislocation.
- Swelling and Bruising: Both injuries will swell, but a fracture will often swell faster and much more severely. The bruising from a fracture can be intense and immediate, though a severe sprain can also result in dark bruising after a day or two.
Can I still walk on a broken ankle?
One of the biggest medical myths out there is the idea that “if you can walk on it, it’s definitely not broken.” This is entirely false.
While severe, displaced fractures will make it physically impossible to put any weight on your foot, minor fractures—such as a small avulsion fracture where a ligament pulls off a tiny piece of bone—might still allow you to limp around. Additionally, in the immediate aftermath of an injury, your body is flooded with adrenaline. This natural painkiller can mask the severity of the injury enough for you to take a few steps.
Medical professionals use the “Ottawa Ankle Rules” as a guideline. If you cannot take four consecutive steps immediately after the injury or during an evaluation without severe pain, you need an X-ray to rule out a fracture. But even if you can walk on it, persistent pain means you should have it checked out by an orthopedic specialist to prevent long-term damage, early arthritis, or chronic instability.
What is the difference between a high ankle sprain and a regular ankle sprain?
Most people who sprain their ankle suffer from a “low” or “regular” ankle sprain. This typically happens when your foot rolls inward (known as an inversion injury). This stretches or tears the ligaments on the outside of your ankle joint.
A high ankle sprain is a different beast entirely. It involves the syndesmotic ligaments, which are located higher up, connecting your two lower leg bones (the tibia and the fibula) just above the ankle joint itself. High ankle sprains usually happen from a forceful outward twisting motion of the foot and leg—often seen in high-impact sports, skiing accidents, or severe twisting falls.
While a regular sprain impacts the stability of the foot itself, a high ankle sprain impacts the stability of the entire lower leg. Every time you take a step, the tibia and fibula are pushed slightly apart, which places repetitive stress on that injured syndesmosis. This constant irritation is exactly why high ankle sprains take significantly longer to heal than regular sprains.
What does a high ankle sprain feel like?
Interestingly, a high ankle sprain might not swell as dramatically or look as severely bruised as a regular ankle sprain. Because the damage is higher up and deeper between the bones, the visible signs are sometimes less obvious, which can lead people to falsely believe it isn’t a severe injury.
However, the pain tells a completely different story. The pain from a high ankle sprain is generally located higher up the leg, above the ankle joint. You might feel a radiating pain shooting up the outside of your calf. A classic diagnostic sign is pain when the foot is rotated outward, or pain when the calf is squeezed just below the knee (known clinically as the “squeeze test”). If twisting your foot away from your other leg sends a sharp, distinctive pain up your shin, you likely have a high ankle sprain.
How long does a sprained ankle take to heal?
The healing timeline depends entirely on the severity, the specific ligaments involved, and how quickly you begin the right treatments:
- Mild to Moderate Low Sprain: Typically takes 2 to 4 weeks to heal with proper rest, ice, compression, and elevation (RICE).
- Severe Low Sprain: A complete tear of the ligaments can take 6 to 12 weeks and may require dedicated physical therapy to regain proprioception and stability.
- High Ankle Sprain: These are notoriously slow healers. A high ankle sprain can take anywhere from 6 weeks to 3 months—or longer—before you feel completely stable returning to high-impact or pivoting activities.
If you have an ankle injury that simply isn’t healing on this timeline, or if you are dealing with chronic ankle pain months after an old injury, it might be time to consider advanced non-operative treatments.
At Easy Orthopedics, we specialize in helping stubborn injuries heal without surgery. We offer targeted interventions like Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) therapy and steroid injections. PRP uses your body’s own concentrated healing factors, drawn from a simple blood sample, to jumpstart the recovery process in damaged tissues. This makes it an excellent option for chronic ankle sprains, partial ligament tears, or lingering inflammation that refuses to resolve on its own.
When should I go to the doctor for an ankle injury?
You should seek immediate medical attention if you experience any of the following “red flag” symptoms:
- Visible deformity or an unnatural angle to the foot or leg.
- Inability to bear any weight or take four consecutive steps.
- Severe, rapidly developing swelling that makes the skin feel tight.
- Numbness, tingling, or a feeling of “pins and needles” anywhere in your foot or toes.
- A cold or pale foot, which can indicate a compromised blood supply.
For everything else—whether it’s a fresh sprain that needs an expert set of eyes or an old injury that still aches when you hike—getting a proper diagnosis early on will save you weeks of frustration.
At Easy Orthopedics in Colorado Springs, we do things differently. Because we are a direct-care, non-insurance-based practice, we completely cut out the frustrating medical red tape. That means you get more direct, uninterrupted time with an orthopedic expert, completely transparent pricing with no surprise bills, and same-day or next-day appointments when you actually need them.
Whether you need a clear diagnosis, a customized non-operative rehab plan, or advanced biologic treatments like PRP to finally get over a lingering injury, we are here to help you get back on your feet. Contact us today to schedule your evaluation and get back to the Colorado activities you love.